Costco Just Got Sued Over a $65 Auto-Renewal — Here's What It Means for Every Subscription You Signed

Meta description: Costco is being sued over auto-renewal notices that allegedly violate California law. Here's what the lawsuit means for your own contracts — and how to spot the same red flags. Target keyword: costco auto-renewal lawsuit california

A Costco member in California got a $65 charge on his credit card in January and went looking for a way to stop it. When he couldn't find the required cancellation details in the renewal email, he sued. Now Costco — one of the most trusted retail brands in the country — is facing a class action lawsuit for sending auto-renewal notices that allegedly violate California state law.

If Costco is getting this wrong, every streaming service, VPN, SaaS tool, and warehouse membership you've signed up for is almost certainly doing worse. And the clauses that make it legal for them to keep charging you are buried in the terms you clicked past without reading.

What Happened

On April 10, 2026, plaintiff Russel George filed George II v. Costco Wholesale Corp. in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California. The complaint alleges that Costco sends its renewal notice email 60 days before the charge hits — outside the 15-to-45 day window required by California's Automatic Renewal Law. It also claims the notices omit statutorily required details: the length and terms of the renewal, the exact amount to be charged, and a clear method to cancel. George says he was "surprised" to find a $65 charge on his card for a Gold Star membership he had been reconsidering. (Top Class Actions coverage)

The suit names four separate legal violations: California's Automatic Renewal Law, the False Advertising Law, the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, and the Unfair Competition Law. A preliminary hearing is set for June 2026.

Costco isn't alone. In the same month, Surfshark VPN was hit with another California class action over auto-renewal charges, and a $1.6 million settlement in the MUBI streaming auto-renewal case received preliminary court approval. The California Attorney General secured a $7.5 million settlement from HelloFresh last year over similar "subscription trap" practices. The pattern is clear: auto-renewal litigation is accelerating, and the clauses inside your subscription contracts are the battleground.

Why This Matters to You

California's Automatic Renewal Law is the strictest in the country, and it sets a floor a lot of companies still can't clear. Under the amended law that took full effect July 1, 2025, businesses must:

If any of those are missing, the renewal is potentially invalid. That's what George is arguing about his Costco membership. And that's also why the last five years of lawsuits against SiriusXM, Adobe, Amazon, The New York Times, Dropbox, and a dozen VPN companies all start with the same complaint: the notice didn't land in the legal window, or the cancel button was buried.

For you as a consumer, here's the practical read. If you're a California resident — and in many cases even if you're not, because companies often apply the strictest state's rules nationally — you have more rights than you're using. A non-compliant auto-renewal is a charge you can often get reversed. The problem is knowing what non-compliant looks like.

And if you're a freelancer, founder, or small business owner running subscription billing yourself, the same rules now apply to you. The settlement numbers in these cases — $1.6M, $7.5M, unknown-millions — are not theoretical. If you send a renewal notice 60 days out instead of 30, you're Costco in miniature. Reading your own contracts before you sign is only half the job — the other half is making sure the ones you issue pass the same test.

What to Check in YOUR Contract Right Now

Pull up any subscription agreement — SaaS tool, gym, streaming service, professional license, SaaS vendor contract, whatever auto-charges you. Here's the five-item checklist.

1. The renewal notice window. Does the contract specify when you'll be notified before the next charge? If it says "reasonable notice" or says nothing at all, that's a red flag. California requires 15 to 45 days for annual plans. If your contract promises less than 15 or allows more than 45, the provider is either non-compliant or writing around the law. 2. The "express affirmative consent" language. A compliant contract says something like "you agree that your subscription will automatically renew at [amount] on [date] unless you cancel." An old-style clause that just buries "services will continue until canceled" inside a wall of terms is no longer good enough in California. If the consent isn't clear and separate, the renewal charge may not be enforceable. 3. The cancellation method. The contract should tell you exactly how to cancel — a URL, a setting, an email address. It should not require a phone call, a physical letter, or a "retention specialist" you have to talk to. "Call 1-800-X during business hours" buried in section 14 is the dark pattern California now prohibits. This one missing sentence has moved from annoyance to active litigation target. 4. The renewal price and term length. You should be told, in the contract, what you'll be charged the next time and for how long. "Then-current rate" with no ceiling is a red flag — it lets the company raise the price silently on renewal. Look for a specific number and a specific term (monthly, annual, multi-year). 5. The refund and reversal policy. Even compliant companies sometimes overcharge. The contract should explain what happens if you dispute a renewal — how fast they'll process the refund, whether there's a window, and what evidence they need. No policy at all means you're at their mercy.

Apply that checklist to three subscriptions you're currently paying for. You will find at least one of them failing on at least two items. That's not paranoia — that's the base rate across the industry right now.

What NovaDocs Catches Automatically

Upload any subscription, SaaS, or membership agreement to novadocs.online and the Auto-Renewal section of the Analysis Panel flags missing notice windows, vague cancellation methods, "then-current rate" language, and absent refund terms — in under 60 seconds. The Payment Terms and Penalties sections catch the secondary issues: hidden late fees, price-escalation clauses, and termination penalties that activate when you try to leave.

Unlike checklists and template libraries, NovaDocs reads your specific contract and maps every finding to the exact sentence in the document. Click a flagged item and the viewer jumps straight to the clause. The Contract Safety Score tells you at a glance whether what you're about to sign is standard, aggressive, or the kind of thing that ends up in a California class action. Freelancers use it for client contracts. Founders use it for vendor SaaS agreements. Consumers use it on memberships they're not sure they should be paying for anymore.

The Bottom Line

The Costco lawsuit is a warning shot, not a freak event. California's auto-renewal law is the strongest in the country, the courts are actively enforcing it, and the companies getting sued aren't fly-by-night operators — they're household names with legal teams who should have caught this.

What that tells you about your own contracts: most of them probably don't meet the standard either. The good news is that non-compliant auto-renewal clauses are often reversible charges, and knowing the five-item checklist above puts you ahead of 95 percent of the people clicking "I agree." For the next subscription that hits your inbox, you know exactly what to look for — and you'll know in the first minute whether it's worth signing.

If you're already paying for a subscription you don't love, pull up the contract today. Run the checklist. If the renewal notice window is wrong, if the cancel path is buried, if the price term is blank — you have a case. Disputing a charge backed by a non-compliant contract is one of the highest-leverage things you can do with ten minutes.

For more on the red flags hiding in everyday contracts, see our breakdown of the patterns clients and vendors use most often.

Upload your contract at novadocs.online and find out in under a minute whether the auto-renewal terms you signed would survive California review.

NovaDocs is a free AI contract intelligence platform. Upload any contract and get instant analysis at novadocs.online.
⚡
NovaDocs Editorial Team

Contract intelligence analysts. We read the contracts so you don't have to. Upload any contract for instant analysis at novadocs.online.

Continue reading on this topic